Should Neville Stand or Sit in Defiance WAS Re: Snape Re: good ides bad idea?

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 115401


 
> SSSusan:
> Well put, Laura--I like that "wrong sides of the same side."  
> 
> My question would be, how would the students in DA take having 
Snape 
> as their advisor?  I agree with all the other points you've made --
  
> DD trusts him, he's in the Order, and he also presumably knows the 
> Dark Arts well.  But these kids have had a really good time with 
> Harry as their leader.  I wonder how they would react if ol' 
Severus 
> showed up to take charge?  (Would be an interesting scene to read, 
> wouldn't it?)
>

Potioncat:
Will the DA need to continue now that Umbridge is gone?  Or will it 
continue as a sort of club?  I can see it now, Professor Snape 
says, "And now let me introduce my assistant...Professor 
Dumbledore..."

You know, actually, it's the sort of crazy thing DD might 
do...assigning Snape to oversee the DA.....Poor Snape.


Potioncat who is somewhat hampered in her current ability to defend 
Snape due to the RL battle she is having with an unreasonable coach 
at her daugher's school.  The coach however has the communication 
skills of a flesh-eating slug.

Whoa, that felt good!

Potioncat, now going off to punish herself by having a nice mug of 
chocolate...