Should Neville Stand or Sit in Defiance WAS Re: Snape Re: good ides bad idea?

[laura]

No: HPFGUIDX 115419


SSSusan:
 
> My question would be, how would the students in DA take having 
Snape 
> as their advisor?  I agree with all the other points you've made --
  
> DD trusts him, he's in the Order, and he also presumably knows the 
> Dark Arts well.  But these kids have had a really good time with 
> Harry as their leader.  I wonder how they would react if ol' 
Severus 
> showed up to take charge?  (Would be an interesting scene to read, 
> wouldn't it?)



  To right it would... but I agree, there is no need for Snape to  
interfear with DA or any of its members... as of yet.  Unless DD see 
some reason to take their "extra curricular actvities" to a higher 
level or purpose, let them have DA to their selves.  If there is a 
reason for the teachers to interject... it will be done, if not... 
let them have their fun.
Hey, I'm a poet and didn't know it!
Happy Posting!
Laura B.