Magic Dishwasher. Was: Re: DD and the rat: Conspiracy theories compared [LONG]

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 115815


> Neri:
> First, I'd like to thank Carolyn for enlivening the forum. It's 
been a
> long time since we had a response from Pip!squeak :-) . 



Alla:

Yes, definitely. It was good to hear from Pip!squeak. I would like 
to use the occassion and point out one more problem I have with MD. 
It is based among other premises on Oscarwinning!Snape(love that 
definition, no matter how strongly I disagree with the substance of 
such premise). I think that even the possibility of Oscarwinnning! 
Snape was destroyed after his raving and raging at Harry after 
occlumency failure, which did lead to a disaster.

That is why I am not quite sure why it had been said so many times 
that OOP strengthened Magic Dishwasher considerably. I felt the 
opposite - that one of its basic premises was destroyed.

Sure, Safe House was strengthened, but Magic Dishwasher? Why?