Snape's stalling

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 116343


> Potioncat:
> I've said it before, this was one of my favorite threads.
> Neri argued that Snape did stall either out of negligence or 
> intent.  Pippin argued he didn't.  And a host of others joined in 
> with arguments or scientific information until an agreed upon 
> timeline was worked out...agreed upon, a miracle in itself.  Of 
> course, no one changed their minds about Snape.  ;-)
> 
> Neri's point with timeline:  108037
> Pippin's points with earlier version of timeline: 107919
> 


Alla:

You know what I still want to know? You probably do. :o) I just 
reread Neri's post with the timeline  and I still wonder - did Snape 
EVER actually go to Forbidden Forest or he just INTENDED to?

To me the answer would say A LOT. Does Snape actually have enough 
humanity in him to actually fear for kids life or did he just do 
what was required from him as Member of OOP(since I am in agreement 
with Neri - I think he did rather sloppy job) and that's it.