Lupin's mind powers was

olivierfouquet2000 olivier.fouquet+harry at m4x.org
Wed Oct 27 17:40:40 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 116553


> > Carol responds:

> > But I didn't mean to get into an anti-conspiracy theory 
> discussion again. I'm only wondering what evidence you have 
> that Lupin has talent as a Legilimens.<
> 
> Pippin:
> 
> All references PoA:
> 
>  In chapter 8, Lupin believes that Harry's boggart would have 
> been Voldemort,   although Harry himself has forgotten that he 
> thought of Voldemort first.
> 
> In chapter 10, Harry is unable to ask his question about why 
> dementors affect him so strongly, but Lupin answers it,  "as 
> though he had read Harry's mind."
> 
> In chapter 17, Lupin is shown "staring so intently at Black it 
> seemed he was trying to read his mind."  
> 
> There are also  hints that Lupin is an Occlumens.
> 
> In chapter 14, Lupin's face assumes an "odd, closed" 
> expression as he contemplates the map. 
> 
> In chapter 19, Snape says, "Don't ask me to fathom the way a 
> werewolf's mind works."
> 
> Granted none of that is proof, but now that we know some 
> characters have mind powers, is it really far-fetched to suppose 
> that the text  hints that Lupin is one of them? "Odd, closed" 
> seems especially obvious.
> 
>> 
> Pippin

Olivier
And if I might add, in chapter 8 PoA, Harry thinks  "for a moment of telling Lupin about the 
dog he'd seen in Magnolia Crescent but decided not to. He didn't want Lupin to think he 
was a coward, especially since Lupin already seemed to think he couldn't cope with a 
boggart."

And then, the punch line "Something of Harry's thoughts seemed to have shown on his 
face, because Lupin said, "Anything worrying you, Harry?""

There are other evidence in OoP. 

Note that if one admits that Lupin is a Legilimens, one can surmise that Lupin knows 
Sirius' first aim is not to kill Harry since the dog did not attack Harry. 

Olivier, quite impressed that Pippin actually wrote a post about Lupin without an 
indictment, seems now and then even she and I can agree about Remus









More information about the HPforGrownups archive