Harry, Hermione, Sirius, and the Dream

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 116796


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Magda Grantwich <

snip.

 Also while the vision of Arthur and the snake had been real, it was
> also clear that this vision was different.  Harry insists that 
there
> had never been anyone in the DoM when he'd been there before and
> Hermione replies that he's never been there, he'd just dreamed 
about
> it before.  And that's our clue that something is very off about 
this
> vision: if Harry's seeing the DoM as he's seen it in what he knows
> are visions from Voldemort's mind rather than as it must be during 
a
> normal working day, then something is badly wrong.


Alla:

I don't understand, Magda. COuld you explain it, please? Are you 
saying that you also fugured that Sirius' dream was fake when you 
first read OOP? I know I did not.

I cannot find any difference between dream about Arthur and Sirius 
and I am not sure how Harry could.

How are Hermione's words that Harry never been there before are 
supposed to be a clue?

Could you clarify, please?

Thank you.