Time-Turner analysis

[Scott]

No: HPFGUIDX 112491

I am suprised that no one has come up with this yet, but here it 
goes.  In PoA, if the person who cast the patronus was Harry then he 
would of have to survive by other means the first time, because the 
stag chased the Dementors away.  So the question becomes what would 
have happened to Harry if the stag did not chase the Dementors away?  
Would they have given Harry the Kiss or would they have left him 
alone after they kissed Sirius.  When JKR put this in the book, I 
don't believe at the time she knew that it was going to be analysed 
so deeply.  I think that we were supposed to look at it like "Oh that 
was Harry who cast the Patronus Stag" and then move on with the story.