"Redemptive pattern" for Snape (was Re: Harry dies sort of.)

totorivers tombadgerlock at freesurf.fr
Sun Sep 12 23:47:10 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 112815

> Alla:
> 
> Sorry, I am still confused. I would be the first one to say that 
IMO 
> Snape was not a victim throughout his wars with Marauders and 
could 
> dish it out quite well, but don't you think judging by Pensieve 
> scene that Snape has  quite a lot to blame James and Sirius for?
> 
> Now, if you would  say for example that Snape blames Marauders for 
> him becoming DE and back it up, then yes, I would agree with you.
> 
> Right now I don't understand your argument, sorry.
> 
> I can see quite a lot of Snape undeservingly blaming Harry for 
> James' mistakes, but that is about it, frankly.

  Ok, i'll better explain myself... I have the impression that Snape 
is trying to makes what James and Sirius Did look on par to what he 
himself did (and yes i see the DE as attacking children, not just 
the parents....DE raid after all, father coming back to see their 
family killed or mad...). I see Part of Snape's hate on them as a 
need to blame them for what he did, as if he was innocent...
Toto






More information about the HPforGrownups archive