The Sneak Mark (was "Slytherin" Hermione?)

[totorivers]

No: HPFGUIDX 112816

> HunterGreen:
> I'm not saying what she did was right, just that it didn't violate 
> *her* values. If Umbridge found out about the group on her own, 
> Marietta would have been expelled along with them, even though she 
> didn't necessarily follow the anti-Umbridge idealogy. And unlike 
> Harry or the Weasleys, she didn't have a family who would 
understand 
> why she was in a group like that. I'm sure her mother would be 
> horrified, and may have already asked her if she knew anything 
about 
> it (or spoke about it in front of her, assuming that she would 
NEVER 
> be in a group like that).

   Any mother would be horrified. As i said before, being expelled 
in the WW means not being *part* of the WW any longer.... and hse 
decidedthat on her own that it was better to make fall others than 
to have a risk for herself. Where are the *values* on that? You are 
saying that she sided with the *ministry* when she knew that the 
ministry changed the rules just to get to certain people... passive 
complicity of abuse is already bad enough, but collaboration with a 
rotten system for no reason but to alleviate one fear? What she did 
*was* like wormtail...and who said wormtail did anything wrong from 
his point of views? People are good to convince themselves....
Toto