The Sneak Mark (was "Slytherin" Hermione?)

mrs_sonofgib tinainfay at msn.com
Tue Sep 14 01:05:09 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 112868

(lots of snipping)
> Pippin:
> >If so, then Hermione usurped Harry's power and only got his 
> consent after the fact. That is an abuse of power similar to that 
of one Dolores Umbridge, and I think the use of a mutilating 
punishment deliberately emphasizes the similarity. Hermione is on a 
rather slippery slope.<

Tina now:
I am, like so many others, a little worried about where Hermione is 
going but as far as the DA is concerned I think she has a leg to 
stand on.  She is the one with idea for the DA.  She does most of 
the speaking at the first meeting.  She decides to have a name, 
officially elect Harry as leader, and have everyone sign up.  She 
also came up with the galleons (for meeting times).  She knows Harry 
well.  He liked the idea of the galleons and mentions to Cho (a bit 
too heartily perhaps) that he thought the Sneak jinx was brilliant.  
Possibly Hermione didn't think she was over-stepping boundaries 
because she knew she would have Harry's support.
~tina






More information about the HPforGrownups archive