Tale of Two Wands - Fawkes as Supplier - When Created?

[gelite67]

No: HPFGUIDX 112987

<snip>

Mac now: Yes, could be, but seems unlikely, even though Ollivander's 
> is LONG established and there's something odd about his appearance 
> (read description in SS/PS) suggesting he's both old and not quite 
> like other wizards.
> 

Angie wonders:  If you mean it is unlikely that the wand had 
languished in the wand shop, then when do you believe it was created?
>

 Mac now: I agree with this (good point Finwitch). Fawkes volunteers 
> (if he chooses) - but is NOT forceable.
> 
<snip>

>Angie replies:  As I indicated to Finwitch,I believe Fawkes would 
give up a feather if DD requested it, I guess in that sense it 
doesn't matter.  My poorly worded point was that a new feather could 
be gained at any time.
> 
<snip>

> Mac wrote:  <snip>It makes me 
> think about whether DD might not give Neville an unknown advantage 
> by having a THIRD feather donated by Fawkes for his specific use 
(as 
> a wand of course) in book 6. I have a theory (earlier post 
> somewhere) that the prophecy could STILL apply to both Harry and 
> Neville, i.e. Harry for one part and Neville for the repeat <snip>

Angie replies:  Good points, both.  I know Neville is going to have a 
larger role to play; can't wait to see what it is.  As for the 
prophesy, I'd wondered about the repeated language, which is not 
repeated verbatim, so I see your excellent point.  I mean, it doesn't 
say that the one marked as LV's equal is the one with the power to 
vanquish him.  Hmmmm . . . .
> 
> <snip>
>