Weak and Evil!Fudge and the missing wands (was: Re: Old Question

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Wed Sep 15 22:32:55 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113075

> HunterGreen wrote:
><snip> Peter, wearing some sort of underclothes, might have taken off
his outer-robes before he transformed (perhaps right after the
explosion, when Sirius was -- I assume -- disoriented). He might have
tossed his wand aside to help further framed!Sirius (he certainly
doesn't have it when he's forced to transform in PoA). <snip>

Carol responds:
Maybe he was wearing Muggle clothes or a second robe. (Was it a robe
or a cloak that Fudge discovered?) I'm guessing that he reappeared in
the Shrieking Shack in PoA wearing the same clothes he wore on the day
he disappeared. Unfortunately, JKR doesn't describe his clothes when
Lupin and Black force him to resume his human form (PoA Am. ed. 366),
but I'm sure she would have said something if he'd showed up in his
underwear. (I don't think he had a chance to obtain other clothes
during the twelve years he was in hiding.) I've noticed that JKR
always writes "robes," plural, so maybe there's an inner and an outer
robe, or maybe "robes" means robe plus cloak. (?)

Carol, picturing a still fat Peter scurrying around in his underwear
searching for clothes






More information about the HPforGrownups archive