Whither the Bezoar?

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Mon Sep 27 13:20:04 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 113990

Kethryn wrote: 
snip
 And, if he does know the whole version, does he accept that Harry 
is the one the prophecy is about or is he holding Neville in 
reserve?  What about the scar, you ask?  Well, theoretical time 
here, Neville is marked by the Dark Lord as much as Harry is only 
his scars are not visible.  How about knowing your parents suffered 
horribly, they will never be normal again and you have to take care 
of them in their infantile state; don't you think that would leave a 
mark as well?
> 
> Kethryn who thinks that is a rather neat theory in and of itself 
but does not expect anyone else to agree with her.

Potioncat:
There have been, and will be again, discussions about Neville's role 
in all this.

Certain clues pop up from time to time.  Harry dreams that he missed 
a quidditch game and was replaced by Neville.  Harry gives Neville's 
name when he gets on the Night Bus.  In two books it is said, "Harry 
was surprised to see Neville..."  one is the "4 students out of bed 
in the middle of the night episode" with McGonagall and the other is 
in OoP when Harry and the other DA members are captured trying to 
talk to Serius. Neville breaks the prophecy orb...

Now, as to what the clues mean, I cannot say.
Potioncat





More information about the HPforGrownups archive