Whither the Bezoar?

[Bex]

No: HPFGUIDX 113991

Kethryn wrote: 
> > And, if he does know the whole version, does he accept that 
> > Harry is the one the prophecy is about or is he holding Neville 
> > in reserve?  What about the scar, you ask?  Well, theoretical 
> > time here, Neville is marked by the Dark Lord as much as Harry 
> > is only his scars are not visible. How about knowing your 
> > parents suffered horribly, they will never be normal again and 
> > you have to take care of them in their infantile state; don't 
> > you think that would leave a mark as well?

Potioncat:
> Certain clues pop up from time to time. Harry dreams that he 
> missed a quidditch game and was replaced by Neville.  Harry gives 
> Neville's name when he gets on the Knight Bus.  In two books it is 
> said, "Harry was surprised to see Neville..."  one is the "4 
> students out of bed in the middle of the night episode" with 
> McGonagall and the other is in OoP when Harry and the other DA 
> members are captured trying to talk to Sirius. Neville breaks the 
> prophecy orb...
> 
> Now, as to what the clues mean, I cannot say.

Yb:
Ahhh, yes, Neville has scars, but they are from the Death Eaters, 
*not* from Voldy. Voldemort did not torture the Longbottoms, Trixie 
and co did. That's one of my main arguments against Neville. As for 
those clues, well, some of us aren't really brave enough to 
speculate... It could be Jo setting us up for something. As much as 
I love Neville, as much as he needs a big moment, I still hold that 
Harry is "The One." Perhaps Neville will fill in for Harry at a big 
confrontation with Voldy, maybe to confuse the bad guy? (Think an 
attack on Sauron's main gates while Frodo take scare of the ring, 
LOTR style.)

~Yb