[HPforGrownups] Whither Harry? (was Re: Whither Snape?

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 127190




>Naama:

>I don't know whether Harry will cause a disaster, but I certainly
>agree with Pippin that JKR has set up the story for a huge clash
>between Harry and Snape.  Harry blames (irrationaly) Snape for Sirius'
>death.  This death has already caused him to cast an Unforgivable -
>feeble though it may have been.  In GoF, Harry fantasises of Crucio-
>ing Snape.
>All this, for me, builds towards Harry casting an Unforgivable curse
>on Snape.  This time, successfuly.  He will probably have (what he
>thinks are) justified reasons - such as believing that Snape is a
>traitor.  Of course, it will turn out to be not true (the way it has
>never been true before).  This, I believe, will bring Harry's moral
>crisis to a head.  By moral crisis I mean Harry's unchecked rage, his
>pride and stubborness, self-pity.  Possibly this is what JKR meant
>when she said that in HBP Harry will have to learn to control his
>emotions.
>It works, I think, with the story as a whole.  Snape consistently has
>been the one person that brings out the worst out of Harry - anger,
>rudeness, baseless suspicions, stubborness, etc.  It's kind of fitting
>that he will be the one that will bring Harry to his lowest moral
>point of his life.


>Thoughts?


>Naama

,%}ry n{3
,i hope ? sc5>io is -pletely wr;g4 ,b my -;ts d1l mo/ly ) ,h>ry's blam+ ( ,snape ov} ,sirius4 ,at ! 5d ( ,,ootp1 ,h>ry 0 9 ! e>ly /ages ( grief1 :5 a p}son w blame "ey"o & any"o1 if "!'s any way 6blame4 ,at ! 2g9n+ ( ,,hbp1 ( c|rse1 ?|< x's be5 two ye>s = u1 x w pick up "r af t fate;l trip 6! m9i/ry4 ,i ?9k ,h>ry's ang} is natural n{1 b ,i ?9k ev5tu,y he w blame hmf mo/ ( all4  ,he'll 2 s busy blam+ hmf1 t he won't 2 blam+ o!rs1 9clud+ ~? :o des}ve ! blame1 ,voldemort & ,bellatrix4 ,my hope is t he w le>n n 6blame hmf or ,snape or ,dum#dore1 2c wa/+ 8 emo;n l t w n help hm 6get hmf "u 3trol4 ,i don't h any 3c}n ab 8 use (! ,cruciatus1 2c 9 8 he>t1 he cd n d x4 ,i don't ?9k he'll 2 a# 6d "o 9 future1 un.s he m/ 6def5d "s"o close 6hm4 ,= ,h>ry1 ! loss ( ,sirius m/ 2 ! f/ r1l & deeply p}sonal grief ( 8 life1 ev5 m 9t5se 2c ( all ! circum/.es surr.d+ ,sirius4 ,h>ry 0 too "y 6h exp}i;ed ? k9d ( grief ov} 8 p>5ts' d1?4 ,s1 6me1 8 feel+s & blame at ! 5d ( ,,ootp >e natural & normal & won't necess>ily turn hm 96"s"o :o cd easily & su3ess;ly use ! un=giva#s4

,%}ry






>------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--
>What would our lives be like without music, dance, and theater?
>Donate or volunteer in the arts today at Network for Good!
>http://us.click.yahoo.com/pkgkPB/SOnJAA/Zx0JAA/s4wxlB/TM
>--------------------------------------------------------------------~-

>Before posting to any list, you MUST read the group's Admin File!
>http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/files/Admin_Files/hbfile.html

>Please use accurate subject headings and snip unnecessary material from posts to which you're replying!

>Yahoo! Groups Links