Yet Another Horcrux Question

pickle_jimmy mkemp at aandr.com.au
Tue Aug 2 13:31:22 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 136056

Voldy gave the Riddle Diary to Mr Malfoy, who was more careless with 
it than he should have been... but, did Voldy give *other* Death 
Eaters parts of his soul too?

RAB perhaps?

Was RAB given the locket to place in the mysterious liquid in the 
cave, but instead placed the non-horcrux necklace there instead?? I 
lean this way because I dont think that if Dumbledore couldnt get 
the locket out of the basin without draining the liquid, anyone else 
could either.

What I am saying is I think that the switch was made before the 
locket ever got to the basin, because I dont think RAB would have 
been able to remove the horcrux locket once in the basin - unless 
he/she drank the liquid, which they obviously didnt as the liquid 
was still there.

Anyway... this leads me to ask if ALL the horcruxes were not given 
to faithful DeathEaters to care for them (or at least hide them 
where Voldy had requested).

================================

And, another musing on a totally different subject - my wife 
suggested that as Harry was released from Dumbledore's spell once DD 
died, maybe the Longbottoms will recover once Belletrix Lestrange 
snuffs it - and maybe Young Mr Longbottom is just the one to do it. 
I am not convinced as I think their brains are more addled than 
still under Her spell, but it is a nice thought.

Cheers

Pickle Jimmy 







More information about the HPforGrownups archive