SHIP: Ginny/Harry, Remus/Tonks, and RL experiences
Lisa Williams
LisaGWilliams at gmail.com
Wed Aug 3 20:26:26 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 136350
Del wrote:
> Lupin/Tonks: I saw the possibility of that one in OoP, and I was
> happy to see it confirmed in HBP. And I simply LOVED the hospital
> scene in HBP, because it relates so closely to my own experience.
> I KNEW what Tonks was going through, because I have had a very
> similar experience. I cry every time I read it, every time I see
> Tonks grabbing Lupin and yelling at him "I don't care!", because
> this is something that I have done and said! I understand the
> Lupin/Tonks dynamics completely, because they are real to me, they
> reflect my experience perfectly.
>
> But I also understand that many other people can't be as touched
> by it, because they haven't been through such an experience, or it
> didn't affect them as much as it did me.
===============================================
Lisa responds:
Ohhhhhhhh, I never thought of it that way, but I did have a similar
occurrence in my past, perhaps that is why I related to it so well!
My "Lupin" held fast to his resolve, however -- and in retrospect, it
was a very good thing. But yes, as soon as I read the "I don't care!"
exchange, I immediately understood and sympathized with Tonks, and I
was shocked that so many didn't see it coming. But perhaps, unless
you have that specific perspective, you're not "looking for it," so to
speak.
Lisa/SassyMommyOfThree
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive