Harry using AK curse?? Yes.

solskjaer_crazy has103 at soton.ac.uk
Sat Aug 6 23:41:26 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 136775

allies426 wrote:
Does anyone think that Harry will be able to use an Avada Kedavra?
I don't!!
 
Eggplant said:
I do. I think Harry will use Avada Kedavra on Snape and Voldemort, and
I hope he will too. Harry is in a war and you can't get squeamish in a
war, if you do the enemy will win and you will end up dead. In the
real world millions of young men just as nice as Harry have been
forced to face this harsh truth and for JKR to shy away from it would
be cowardly. If JKR makes Harry get all warm and fuzzy when he
confronts his enemies in the final big confrontation we all know is
coming in book 7 it will be a dreadful book.

And now me:
I don't know if he will but I certainly hope he doesn't.
Unfortunately I can't rememer the quote and I can't remember where it 
is (I think it's book 4 somewhere but I might be wrong) because I 
haven't read the books in ages and am currently starting my first
read through after book 6 but isn't there a passage somewhere where
someone (I think one of the Weasleys or fake Moody) talks about the 
Ministry authorising Aurors to use the unforgivables against people 
and that this is being a bad thing in there opinion, almost as though 
it brings them down to the level of the death eaters? I definitely 
remember it being said because it's mentioned that Moody never did
use the unforgivables to bring people in and always bought them in 
honestly. So wouldn't Harry using AK on Snape or Voldemort be the 
same? Surely the point is that there are other ways for him to do
what he needs to do and by using the unforgivables on them he makes
himself no better than them since these spells are dark arts based on 
hate and anger and not on love and trust, I don't know about anyone 
else but every time Harry tries to use one of them I always get a 
really odd feeling that I can't quite pin point and find myself 
thinking "no harry, don't".

Holly
*Who feels she's now pushing her luck with keep stepping on people's 
toes and is going to shut up*






More information about the HPforGrownups archive