Snape's Pensieve Memories (Was: Snape's Pensieve)

[houyhnhnm102]

No: HPFGUIDX 137092

 Carol responds:

> First I want to note that Dumbledore's memories would not have been
> mixed with Snape's. 

houyhnhnm:

I wasn't suggesting that they were, only that, since the idea to teach
Harry occlumency is Dumbledore's and the pensieve is Dumbledore's, it
must have been Dumbledore who was concerned about Snape's memories
either influencing Snape or being seen by Harry.

For the rest of your comments, I pretty much agree. It doesn't make
sense.  If being up-ended and up-robed at the age of 15 really is
Snape's worst memory, it kind of blows the ESE Snape theory out of the
water.

> Carol, who thinks that Draco, Snape, and Dumbledore fell together into
> a trap of Voldemort's making

houyhnhnm:

I definately agree with that!