Snape and Voldemort WAS:Dumbledore and Snape again

[Julia]

No: HPFGUIDX 137313

colebiancardi:
<snip>
> Snape is much more useful as a undercover agent in Voldy's camp 
and 
> he can continue to protect Draco.  Since Snape killed DD, or it 
> *seems* that Snape killed DD - I think DD was a dead man the 
minute 
> he got cursed by the horcrux ring and all Snape did was push him 
over 
> the side and perhaps released him from any spell/potions that was 
> keeping DD alive - and he has other DE's that have witnessed it, 
> Snape is probably Voldemort's *best-boy* right now.  And that may 
> have clout - which Snape will use to protect Draco & make sure 
> Voldemort doesn't take it out on him. 
> 
> I still believe, however, that Snape cannot survive book 7.  He 
will 
> give up his life for either Harry or Draco to survive.  And that 
is 
> how he will be redeemed.
> 
> Of course, that is JMHO
> 
Julia:

It just occured to me so I thought I'll share it with you guys. What 
if Voldemort wouldn't be very pleased with Snape killing Dumbledore? 
I know Voldemort wants DD dead but it wasn't his goal when he gave 
Draco the Mission... I mean - Voldemort (along with Narcissa)was 
probably sure that Draco will chicken out or be killed in an attempt 
to AK Dumbledore... It was simply a plan to get rid of the Malfoys 
or to give a lesson to Lucius. IMO Voldemort didn't plan to kill 
Dumbledore at that point - that whole plan was about Draco and the 
Malfoys.

When Narcissa with Bellatrix show up at Snape's door and Severus 
makes an Unbreakable Vow everything change. IMO neither Nercissa nor 
her sister told Voldemort about the Vow so imagine his surprise when 
he finds out that out of blue Snape (who wasn't informed about the 
Mission or when Draco will attempt to fulfill it) turns out at the 
crime scene AKs Dumbledore grabs Draco and runs away... Isn't it  
suspicious? And even if DL doesn't suspect a treachery it should 
occur to him that this situation is somehow strange... Nobody but 
Draco was supposed to kill Dumbledore (when Fenrir loses it and try 
to approach DD someone stops him!)

No I wonder if Snape wouldn't have a hard time explaining how did he 
knew about the Mission (I'm absolutely sure that he lied to Narcissa 
and he didn't know about Draco mission to kill DD) and WHY exactly 
did he kill DD?? It would be much more harder for Snape cause if he 
wanted to tell the truth he would have to tell about Narcissa and 
Bellatrix... 

A classic tragic situation
What do you think?

Julia