Dumbledore and Snape again. WAS: Re: Missing Horcrux = Ravenclaw's

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 137438



Jazmyn:
   Its remarkable stupidity on the part of the 
> characters that not a single one that knew about Snape's vow did 
not 
> realise that Snape would have DIED if he did not kill Dumbledore.

Alla:

I think it was remarkable stupidity on the part of Snape to TAKE this 
Vow , personally, if he is one of the good guys.


Jazmyn:

  Was he calling him a coward for NOT 
> throwing his life away to save a dying old man who was outliving 
his 
> usefullness to the cause??  Sorry, If I was Snape, as hard as it 
would 
> have been, I would have done the same thing just to reduce 
casualties 
> and protect the cause.  Dying and having others die, who may be key 
to 
> winning the war would have been utterly foolish.
> 


Alla: 

We don't KNOW that Dumbledore outlived his usefullness to the cause, 
on the contrary, it seems to me that he was VERY much needed to 
finish Harry's education if nothing else.
He also was planning putting Draco into hiding

We also don't know whether DD would have been able to escape if Snape 
started fighting with DE.


Alla,

who hopes to see Snape dead in the book 7,regardless of the reasons 
he killed Dumbledore, because he has way too much blood on his hands 
to get a happy ending, IMO