It's over, Snape is evil ( was: No Snape is not evil!)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 137416

"oiramertip" <mario.pitre at v...> wrote:


> He did not already have LV's trust.
> The all pretend to be his closest 
> advisor. 

Snape didn't say that, Draco's mother said it, and if she didn't
believe it  why was she there asking for help?

> Snape only pretended to know of LV's plan. 

So Snape made an Unbreakable Vow to help the plan when he didn't even
know what he was vowing to do? That's ridiculous. 

> He did not ask anyone for murder.
> He is not dead. 

I thought you said Snape would be "showing Harry a DD memory in the
pensieve that will show DD asking Snape to kill him.... for that
specific purpose of getting ultra- close to LV"
And anyway, don't you realize how dreadful the next book will be if it
turns out Dumbledore's death was just a silly hoax?

> He did not tell Harry, because Harry 
> does his best thinking and 
> fighting when he is on his own. 

Because Dumbledore did not tell Harry this means Harry hates Snape at
least as much as he hates Voldemort and may place an even higher
priority on killing him. If Harry and Snape are really on the same
side but they are trying to kill each other this would be a blunder of
cosmic proportions on Dumbledore's part. Serious died because
Dumbledore kept Harry in the dark about something, I don't think he's
make the same mistake again.

Eggplant