Why didn't DD tell all Voldy = TR? (was: Marriage at Hogwarts and in the WW)
cubfanbudwoman
susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Tue Aug 16 15:55:45 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 137800
SSSusan:
> > But the question of why DD didn't tell the whole WW that TR = LV
> > is still intriguing, no?
a_svirn:
> I don't see how it would make any difference. Most DE surely know
> LV's previous name.
<snip>
> Maybe no one asked? Dumbledore doesn't strike me as a type to write
> open letters to the Daily Prophet
SSSusan, quite obviously behind in reading posts:
You're correct, a_svirn, that at least *some* of the DEs have to be
familiar w/ Voldy's given name, as they were associates [hesitate to
use the word "friends" based upon DD's comments] during Tom's time at
Hogwarts.
Still... I keep thinking back to Bellatrix's reaction at the MoM,
when Harry made the pronouncement about Voldy being a half-blood.
She spluttered and denied and was generally royally kerfuffled by
this. *That* implied, to me, that some DEs were not in the know --
even Bella, who clearly had been pretty high up on Voldy's list
(although not long out of Azkaban, either).
Maybe you're right -- maybe nobody asked, or maybe they knew the
*name* but didn't know the family history. So perhaps the better
question is: Why didn't DD broadcast both who Voldy really was and
*what* he really was? It sure seems suspicious to me that he
didn't. I mean, DD's making such an announcement might well have
lost Voldy some supporters among the pureblood set.
Siriusly Snapey Susan
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive