Faked death or faked AK?/Plan? What Plan?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 138150

> >
> >Sarah:
> >Why would they want Harry to know the truth?  That is  the best 
part
> >of the whole plan.  Harry never learned Occlumency, LV can look 
into
> >his head any time he wants.  Now when he does, he won't see 
anything
> >but his best uberminion being superloyal.
> <snip>

Alla:

Well, I believe that in light of Dumbledore statement that Voldemort 
is now employing Occlumency against Harry, the chance that he would 
indeed look and risk Harry seeing his secret plans is not very high.

I believe that if indeed Dumbledore and Snape planned anything, they 
definitely should have told Harry in light of that, because that 
would be so not smart, IMO to increase Harry's hatred of someone who 
is supposed to help him at the crucial moment, or even if that 
someone is just supposed to pass him some crucial information.

So, I am with Sherry, if such plan existed, I would consider the 
executution of it to be very poorly thought out.


 
> Fabian:
> Clever indeed, however, what about all the other ones of the 
Order? They 
> all know Snape is with them for real, and playing LV, at least 
that's 
> the feeling I get from reading the beginning of OoTP. They can't 
all be 
> that good at Occlumency, can they?
> 
Alla:

I agree. Surely Dumbledore and Snape would wanted to have at least 
one ally in the Order who could have maybe collected information and 
pass it to Harry, no?

Anyways, whether Harry would be proven right or wrong at the end and 
as I said earlier my suspicion is that he would be proven right for 
the major part ( as in Snape indeed killed DD because of his 
cowardice, but he may commit some act of redemption at the end), I 
really like that Harry is not alone now in his mistrust of Snape.


This is of course only my opinion,

Alla.