Faked death or faked AK?/Plan? What Plan?
Auria
rytal at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Aug 20 02:02:15 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 138157
> > Fabian:
> > Clever indeed, however, what about all the other ones of the
> Order? They
> > all know Snape is with them for real, and playing LV, at least
> that's
> > the feeling I get from reading the beginning of OoTP. They can't
> all be
> > that good at Occlumency, can they?
> >
> Alla:
>
> I agree. Surely Dumbledore and Snape would wanted to have at least
> one ally in the Order who could have maybe collected information and
> pass it to Harry, no?
Auria:
Dont forget that 'LV is the most accomplished legilimens the world has
ever seen'. This means that he could easily read anyones thoughts
including those in the Order. As Snape is himself an accomplishes
occlumens, and LV seems to trust him, Snape is the only person
Dumbledore can trust with such delicate and important plans to defeat
LV. This may make some sense as to why Harry or seemingly other
members of the Order would not know that Dumbledore has faked his own
death - its to protect both the plan and the Order members, who could
be targets if LV ever suspected them of knowing something.
Auria
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive