YES ( was: Did Snape "murder" Dumbledore?)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138209

"colebiancardi" <muellem at b...> wrote:

> Full nasty mode to you, perhaps. 
> We've seen Snape be a heck of lot
> more nasty. Was he calling Harry names? 

No, Snape did not call Harry a doodoo head or some other nasty name so
he gets one brownie point for that, but he did murder Dumbledore and I
thing he should be fined one or two brownie points for that. Don't you?

> why didn't Snape take Harry with them? 

Why would Snape want to do that? And take Harry where?

> why didn't Snape let the other DE kill him? 

Because Snape made an Unbreakable Vow to protect the life of Harry
Potter until he kills Voldemort.

> Flitwick is a child? Tonks is a child?
> Lupin is a child? Hey, there were some
> adults there - why didn't Snape kill them? 

Snape is evil and Snape is a villain but Snape is not a homicidal
maniac, he does not kill people when it not necessary. It is necessary
to kill Dumbledore (and Voldemort) if he is to be the most powerful
wizard in the world.

> [outnumbered] 100 to 1? Really? 

Yes, really.

> I only counted 6 OotP members at the base of the tower

And about 600 wizards in other parts of the castle they wanted to get
out of after the murder.

Eggplant