Hermione saves Snape?

ellecain ellecain at yahoo.com.au
Sat Aug 20 17:15:33 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 138213

Before I start, I've got to congratulate Saraquel on the
plausible cave finding explanation.
Thought it was excellent and v.likely.
Also thanks Jessica for the rush of excitement I got
on finding my first ever post had not only been read but replied to.

To get to the point-
Asssuming the DumbledoresMan!Snape theory which I
stubbornly refuse to let go of... Snape is in a
really difficult position here, since he must convince someone
that he is ESG! before they kill him on the spot.
And I think the person to discover that he was ESG! all along will 
be Hermione.
Remember in HBP where Harry calls him evil? And Hermione says
"Evil is a strong word to use"
This indicates that she may still have a reasonable doubt
of Snape's guilt. Maybe she goes off on her own to 
find him as she wants to be convinced on his (lack of) guilt.
Then she becomes his ally and Snape feeds information to Harry 
through her?
Any takers?

Elyse
(who is not getting any work done since stumbling onto this 
messageboard)










More information about the HPforGrownups archive