It's over, Snape is evil (but maybe not 100%)

[delwynmarch]

No: HPFGUIDX 138307

Eggplant wrote:
"Yes that's true, in fact the only hope Snape lovers have is if
Dumbledore is not really dead and the entire climax of book 6 was all
just a colossal hoax or practical joke; but if we learn in book 7 that
it's true then millions of people will be storming bookstores
demanding their money back. There is no way a plot twist like that
could produce a satisfactory book."

Del replies:

1. Just because YOU wouldn't be satisfied with such a book doesn't
mean that nobody else would.

2. You're the one who keeps reminding us that JKR has no duty towards
her readers. If millions of readers are disappointed after Book 7, so
what? Nobody forced them to buy any of the books.

Eggplant wrote:
"By the way, I predicted right after book 4 came out that Dumbledore
would die at the end of book 6; I also predicted Harry would die at
the end of book 7.  "

Del replies:
Like many other people, including me. But you also predicted that
Harry would turn into Dirty!Harry in HBP, and would start kicking
behinds. You've now transferred that prophecy to Book 7, I've noticed.

Eggplant wrote:
"Right again, but when one character has a look of extreme insane
hatred on his face when he murders another character it's not terribly
difficult to deduce what that character is feeling."

Del replies:
Good for Harry that DD didn't actually die when Harry was
force-feeding him the Cave Potion, then.

I just don't get it why you have to be so condescending and hurtful
with people who don't share your opinion...

Del