It's over, Snape is evil (but maybe not 100%)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138319

"delwynmarch" <delwynmarch at y...> wrote:

> Just because YOU wouldn't be satisfied
> with such a book [Dumbledore's death 
> just being a hoax or joke] doesn't
> mean that nobody else would. 

I believe the very first person who would be disappointed with such a
book is JKR.

> You're the one who keeps reminding 
> us that JKR has no duty towards her readers. 

Yes, but she does have a duty not to betray her genius. 

> you also predicted that Harry would 
> turn into Dirty! Harry in HBP, and 
> would start kicking behinds. You've
> now transferred that prophecy to
> Book 7, I've noticed.

Quite true, only now it's not so much a prediction as a wish.

> I just don't get it why you have to
> be so condescending and hurtful with
> people who don't share your opinion

I shall strive harder in the future to be just like you who never
criticizes anyone or personalizes anything and who's scrupulous
politeness makes Dumbledore look like a boor. 

Eggplant