DD's definitely dead (Snape)?
strawberryshaunie
strawberryshaunie at yahoo.ca
Mon Aug 22 02:42:40 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 138352
Luckdragon said (with much snipping):
If anyone could prevent [DD's] death from the potion it was Snape,
who if I recall correctly told his first year potion students that
"he
could
teach them to put a Stopper on death".
I know this has been discussed before, and the actual quote is still
open to interpretation, but Snape actually said "a stopper IN death".
This makes a huge difference, because it means Snape's talking about
bottling poison, not an antidote. "Stopper" means cork or lid,
meaning
he could teach anyone with enough competence to make and cork death
in
a bottle. (I'm not arguing that Snape isn't up to making antidotes, I
agree that if anyone could do it, it would be him, but this might
provide some insight into his motives and priorities...he chooses to
mention his skills with poisons rather than how to counteract them-a
clue perhaps? Who filled that basin anyway?)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive