It's over, Snape is evil (was: Dumbledore and Snape again)

[eggplant107]

No: HPFGUIDX 138435

Lisa Williams <LisaGWilliams at g...> wrote:

> I don't believe Snape knew that Narcissa 
> would ask for an Unbreakable Vow -- I 
> think he was trapped into it. Turn her down,
> and he arouses DE suspicion that he's 
> on Dumbledore's side.

Narcissa was not Snape's boss, if Voldemort did not insist he make an
unbreakable vow I don't see how she could. Of course it's possible
Snape had already made such a vow to Voldemort and he was just
repeating it to Narcissa.

> Dumbledore knew of Draco's plan, 
> Snape obviously told him 

That's not obvious to me at all. We are not told how Dumbledore found
out but he told Snape to keep an eye on it, a big mistake on
Dumbledore's part.

> I can certainly see the other 
> side of the argument too. 

The polite thing would be for me to say I can see the other side of
the argument too, but in all honesty I can not because none of the
reasons I've heard why a good Snape would murder Dumbledore make one
bit of sense. Zero nada zilch.

Eggplant