[HPforGrownups] What would Snape have to do....

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 138555



doddiemoemoe:

>He's responsible for the deaths of Lilly and James Potter.

Juli: why because he heard half a prophesy? he had no idea it refered to the Potters. 

>He's even responsible for Harry being the chosen one.

Juli: again why are you so sure of this? As I see it it's no one's fault but Voldemort's.


>He's cruel to Neville, Hermione and Harry.

Juli: actually I agree

He's responsible for the fate of Neville's parents.

Juli: Why so? Bellatrix, Barty Jr, Rabastan and Rodolphous tortured Mr and MRs Longbottom. What's Snape's part in all of these?


>He made an unbreakable vow to ensure DD was killed. (or that Harry 
would be killed in some theories)

Juli: Forgive me, but do you know for a fact that Snape knew Draco's task? Or if he did, how could he gotten away without performing the UV with Narcissa?

>He let slip that Lupin was a werewolf.

Juli: After keeping the secret for about 15 years, and after making Wolfsbane all year... I think he was just hurt, he hated himself for letting Sirius get away.

>He let slip that Sirius was an animagus. (causing him to be an 
absolute prisoner in OOP--and please note that as rash, angry and 
irritable as Sirius became he still never revealed that Snape was 
a "double spy" or even that he was a DE.)

Juli: Where does it say so? I though Peter Pettigrew told Voldemort about Sirius' animagus capabilities. And also, when does exactly Snape find out that Sirius is an animagus?
He states he passed the information to have Vance killed.

>He joined the DE's of his own accord, he didn't back out right away either(he "left" for completely different reasons than Regulus Black for example).

Juli: Where's the canon to it? AFAIK we don't really know why he joined the DEs in first place.

>With this much blood, heartache and sorrow....how can he possibly 
redeem himself?!?!?

Juli: But there's so much of his life we don't know about, mostly we've seen him though Harry's eyes, and they are not objective. So maybe Snape has even redeemed himself. WHo knows!

 


Juli
Aol: jlnbtr
Yahoo: jlnbtr



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]