Does Snape bully Neville in HBP?

Marianne S. schumar1999 at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 26 02:55:40 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 138764

 > Finwitch:
> 
> Oh, I know why:
> 
> Mainly that Snape doesn't wish Dumbledore to know beyond doubt that 
> he bullies a student. Now that Harry's having private Lessons with 
> Dumbledore and Slughorn is having his Club (where Neville, Harry and 
> Hermione are all invited to) some adult would definately know and do 
> something about it.

Marianne S:

Is there any evidence that Neville is invited to the Slug Club after 
the initial train ride? IHarry seemed to think that Slughorn was reserving 
judgement on Neville when on the train, and I don't recall Neville's 
name ever coming up in conjunction with Slughorn at any future time. 
He wasn't one of his potions students, either. It seemed to me that
not all the students who received the initial invites remained 
"in the club" and Hermione was the only one I noticed being added
later because of Merit, not just connections. 









More information about the HPforGrownups archive