Snape's remorse (was:ACID POPS vs LOLLIPOPS (was:Whom does Snape REALLY love

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 139077


> 
> Valky:
> I would like to
> register my agreement that these could be Snape (or more likely JKR)
> laying clues about Harry's parents.
> 
> The reason I say this is because of the other question that Snape
> poses to Harry.
> What is the difference between Monkshood and Wolfsbane.
> Tranlsated in the tradition that Lady Indigo proposed:
> 
> What is the difference between Chivalry and Misanthropy. 
> 
> WE have seen *that* debate SO! many times here about James in the
> Pensieve. ROFL
> 
> Valky

Valky, again, replying to her own post dry retches as she places the
LOLLIPOP in her mouth, her faces screws up in displeasure, her ACID
POP dangling uselessly by her side:

Blehhh! I am not doing this because I like it you know. The facts just
speak for themselves, don't they. The above is no less an allusion to
Snapes relationships with Harry's parents that I am a fanatic LOLLIPOP
detractor for said reasons. <Screws up her face in disgust> I'm still
A Siriusly James Potter girl.

In HBP Dumbledore merely says that Snape regretted what Voldmeort
planned to do to people he knew from school. DD didn't specify James
or Lily, he just implied both to some degree. Harry naturally disgreed
that Snape would give a damn about his father, nothing more was said
by either in regard to Lily. I can't continue to try and construe this
to James, when the allusion in Snapes first ever scene is so clear
now. Snape's regret, his bitterness, his draught of living death is
Lily Potter. My prayers have been answered and the answer is NO. The
good ship Lollipops will not sink. <g>

I recal not far back that there were some of us here, contemplating
how HP tends to echo itself. And discussing wether the scenes of Harry
and Snapes confrontation in Book seven will echo the Shrieking Shack. 
I think it was Alla who said she hoped Harry would echo DD in HBP
saying to Snape "It is my mercy that matters now, not yours"

I have just realised that if Lollipops still sails by mid Book seven,
then the Shireking Shack all over again it definitely is.

Lets just say that "That awful boy." is Severus Snape. What happens
when Harry tells his Aunt "Snape killed Dumbledore." Would she
recognise the name, and tell Harry that Severus was Lily's friend.
hat if he comes across memories of a friendship between Snape and Lily
as he searches through Godrics Hollow.

Then what happens when Hary and Snape cross paths? Worse things now
are revealed to Harry than the death of Dumbledore. "You were her
friend! She stood up for you alone that day, and you betrayed her! You
were my mothers friend!" 
Can Snape make the same claim as Sirius, would he rather have died
than ever betray someone he cared for. No. But he cannot grovel at
Harrys feet like Pettigrew either. So what will Snape do, when Harry
finally forces him to look into his Mother's eyes? 

Valky
Wishing she was firing canons at the hull insted.