It's over, Snape is evil (was: Dumbledore and Snape again)

[Matt]

No: HPFGUIDX 139231

--- Finwitch wrote:
> Considering that Snape told the Black Sisters he had 
> given Voldemort information that led to Sirius' death as 
> well as that of Emmeline Vance... he might have lied about 
> nearly all else, but NOT on that.
> ........ 
> Dumbledore believed Kreacher did it ....
> I'd say that Snape framed Kreacher - even as Tom Riddle 
> framed Morfin.

So are you hypothesizing that Snape modified Kreacher's memory? 
Dumbledore says that he needed to use Legilimency to get the story out
of Kreacher, but I guess the hypothesis would also include Dumbledore
failing to detect the memory modification.

(Sorry, just catching up with this.)

-- Matt