It's over, Snape is evil (was: Dumbledore and Snape again)

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 138820

"colebiancardi"  wrote:

--Although DD told
> him that Snape did everything the night that Sirius died, Harry
> *still* wanted to believe that it was Snape's fault. He didn't care
> what DD was telling him.

Finwitch:

Considering that Snape told the Black Sisters he had given Voldemort 
information that led to Sirius' death as well as that of Emmeline 
Vance... he might have lied about nearly all else, but NOT on that. 
Harry's instinct proved right in this case.

Dumbledore believed Kreacher did it by telling one of these Black 
Sisters about Sirius' relationship to Harry and yet so that Kreacher 
was unable to betray them totally... (But - there was no such 
restrictions on Snape - apart from his not being the Secret Keeper - 
and the person Kreacher had supposedly been conversing with, was 
sitting there in that very room) - so um - I don't think Harry was 
all *that* wrong, after all...

I'd say that Snape framed Kreacher - even as Tom Riddle framed Morfin.

Finwitch