Horcrux in each book?
allies426
AllieS426 at aol.com
Fri Dec 2 20:21:55 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 143927
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "spotsgal" <Nanagose at a...>
wrote:
> Musicgal
> I personally think the Gryffindor decendant is a Weasley. The
> whole "seven" thing comes into play again, AND they're all
> pureblood, AND they have red hair AND they've all been in
> Gryffindor...they also have special relics of olden times, like
> the tiara that belonged to Mrs. Weasley's great aunt or something.
Christina:
I think that they are a very good candidate (I think that Harry as
the
heir of Gryffindor is so cliche, but that's just me); however, you
run
into some thematic problems with that one I think. If JKR wants to
make the descendents of Gryffindor thematically important, it'd be
easiest for her to do if there was basically one surviving descendent
(like with Tom Riddle). If the entire Weasley clan is heir to
Gryffindor, then who steps up to represent it? Remember, it's not
just our 9 Weasleys that are in the family; they have cousins and
other relatives too.
Allie:
Don't know why, but when you said "one suviving descendant" my brain
said NEVILLE LONGBOTTOM. The unlikeliest of unlikely but who
knows! I'm still waiting for Neville's shining moment - he made so
much progress in OoTP and then couldn't hit a single death eater
with a curse when it counted!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive