Who does Snape really hate?

Wan Norjihan norjihan at yahoo.com
Sun Dec 4 14:11:34 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144081

> Radasgat:
> > For a bit of dramatic irony.. who does Snape "appear" to 
> > love?  Draco. What is Draco? The only son of an older 
> > couple who has been doted on his whole life and given his 
> > every wish and desire...similiar so James? <snip>

> Valky: 
> I think there is something in his [Snape's] point of view 
> that could explain this. Father figures.
>  <snip>
> It's no stretch to imagine that Snape could be very similar 
> to Draco here. <snip> Also we have the snippet of memory 
> which shows that Snape's father was probably abusive to his 
> wife and cold to his son.
> 
> <snip> Snape probably sees a lot of himself in Draco and
> empathises more readily with him, so in contrast Harry is 
> a spoiled celebrity brat because from Snape's POV he will 
> always have a fathers love.


In the first five books, it looks like Snape likes Draco very 
much, or is it really?  Because in the HBP their relationship 
seems to deviate, Draco no longer try to get Snape's attention 
because he doubt Snape's true identity and loyalty.  And Snape 
no longer treats Draco the way he used to, is it because Lucius 
is now in Azkaban, so he need not to pretend anymore.

Snape came from a troubled family, there're lots of things that 
he wanted in his life that he never got, so, there're certain 
emotions trapped inside him, a father who gave attention (in a 
child and teenager POV)- like how Draco got from Lucius, a 
popularity like what James and Sirius had, a friend loyalty and 
great friendship like James-Sirius-Lupin-Pettigrew(?) got.  So, 
when the emotions was trapped inside, he can't let go his 
childish grudge, even though he is a genius.

Remember, high IQ doesn't promised any high EQ....

"norjihan"








More information about the HPforGrownups archive