Whom did Snape kill or conspired to kill? WAS: Forgiving Snape

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 144369

> > Bart:
> > Please name one life that we know was taken due to Snape's spy 
work for 
> > Voldemort. I don't know of any; only those that Snape CLAIMED 
were lost 
> > to the Black sisters.

Sherry:
> > How about James and Lily potter?  There are two names for you. 
> Bart:
> 	There is a difference between passing on overheard 
information and 
> actively working as a spy. It is still a question mark for whom 
Snape is 
> working; although surface appearances certainly point towards his 
> working for Voldemort, there is considerable evidence that he was 
> working for the Order, or, more precisely, Dumbledore.


Alla:

Are you arguing that when Snape told Prophecy to Voldemort he 
actually did it on Dumbledore's request? 

I would say that makes Dumbledore not only manipulative, but slipping 
into Evil quite fast. JMO, obviously.

I don't see Dumbledore risking the lives of unknown couple and baby 
for some manipulative reasons, but more importantly I do not remember 
any considerable evidence in canon pointing that Dumbledore sent 
Snape to tell the Prophecy to Voldemort. I can be wrong of course, so 
could you please point me to those evidence, if you don't mind?


Oh, and going back to lives lost because of Snape. It is of course 
your prerrogative to not believe what he tells Bella and Cissy, I do 
for the most part. But most importantly while we do know that 
Kreacher went to tell the information to Malfoys about Sirius ( I 
still think that there is nothing to prevent Snape to duplicate 
Kreacher's efforts, but we do have opposite evidence at least), we 
have NOTHING, IMO to argue that anybody else is gulty in Emmeline 
Vance death, but Snape. 

Snape said it, there is no canon to show that he did not do it, IMO, 
so I am inclined to take his word for it.


Of course, just my opinion.

Alla.