Nagini as a Horcrux and the torturing of the Longbottoms

allies426 AllieS426 at aol.com
Fri Dec 9 19:54:25 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 144419

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Bonnie Harvey/ Alesia 
Gillefalyn" <alesiaglfyn at j...> wrote:
>
 We know from HBP that the 
> creation of a Horcrux requires both a potion and a spell, 
> therefore it make sense it requires some time to create.

Allie:

Do we know this?  I don't remember a potion being part of it.

> Has anyone ever suggested the DEs who tortured the Longbottoms, 
> after the death of the Potters, for information about LV were 
> really after the location of LV's body? Could it be possible they 
were attempting to locate the body so they could reunite his soul 
(the vapor we see in PS/SS) and his body.   With Frank and Alice 
> both being Aurors, it makes sense they might have known where the 
> Ministry moved LV's body to.  To me, it has always been pretty 
> clear the way LV regained his body in GoF wasn't the original 
> plan and there was another way he had planned on had he still had 
> access to his original body.  
> 

Allie again:

That's interesting, I had always thought that Voldemort (and his 
body) was vaporized when the AK rebounded on him.  *WAS* his body 
just lying there in the ruin?  I've never heard mention of a body 
before.  But if there was no body, that brings up the question of 
how did anyone know he was gone?  Unless someone else was there and 
witnessed it (conspiracy theorists, take your pick:  
Snape/Peter/Lupin/Hagrid/Dumbledore).









More information about the HPforGrownups archive