Is DD Portrait Really Different From Others? WAS: Snape & Dumbledore

[h2so3f]

No: HPFGUIDX 144486

Jade wrote: 
"I tend to agree with him (DD) physically gone, however, it still 
bugs me that his portrait is not interacting like the rest of them. 
I also have my reservations about Snape and the tower incident. 
There are things that just doesn't add up to think Dumbledore 
wouldn't be involved in some way in the last book. Just don't know 
what."


CH3ed:
I think DD is dead dead and that the portrait is a good indication 
of that. As to DD portrait 'not interacting like the other 
portraits' when Harry saw it briefly while he was in the 
Headmaster's Office with McGonnagal and other teachers, I don't see 
that that constitutes a definite proof that it is not like other 
portraits. DD had just died. Perhaps all portraits snooze a lot when 
they first appear. We don't know, ay? We've never seen a freshly 
appeared one until this of DD. Besides they all seem to snooze (real 
or fake) a lot thru out the series.

CH3ed doesn't think he would want his loved ones to reappear as 
interactive portraits after they died.... Gosh! wouldn't that be 
weird when you're in mourning?