Who killed Dumbledore? WAS: Re: Karmic justice in Potterverse again.

[zgirnius]

No: HPFGUIDX 145091


> Allie:
> 
> Interesting, and I *think* you're the first to suggest that 
particular 
> scenario.  It leaves room for AnySide!Snape, possibly explains why 
> Dumbledore was blasted off the tower (we don't know WHAT happens if 
the 
> AK is directed at something that is already dead), and doesn't make 
> Snape a murderer.  Now I have to reread that scene...
>
zgirnius:
Credit where credit is due...I may be the first person to mention it 
here, but it is not my theory, I'm not that clever. I found in on the 
website of Red Hen.

I do like the theory, even if I am not sure I believe it. 

By the way, the verb 'blast' is definitely used to describe the effects 
of an AK hitting an inanimate object elsewhere in the series.