Real child abuse/ Mcgonagall

[amiabledorsai]

No: HPFGUIDX 145599

 Jazmyn Concolor wrote:
> If someone had gone into my most private thoughts, I would have
> been a lot more violent then Snape.  

Amiable Dorsai:
*You* have the right to keep your thoughts private.  Harry could
reasonably conclude that Snape doesn't, not from Harry. 


Jazmyn:
> What Harry did was unforgivable, carelessly diving into the
> private thoughts of not only another person, but a teacher and a
> member of the Order of the Phoenix.  

Amiable Dorsai: 
And a man who, unprovoked, has been making Harry's life hell for five
years--and whose training in Occlumency has had the apparent
side-effect of opening Harry's mind even further to Voldemort.  Harry
took an opportunity to get intelligence on the enemy--and, whether
he's DDM or not, Snape has given Harry plenty of reason to believe
that he's Harry's enemy


Jazmyn:
> The pensieve was in use to keep Harry away from those memories
> and he knew it and  violated the pensieve anyways.  Secrets he
> could have picked up from this in the wrong memory might have
> made him a terrible danger to the cause.

Amiable Dorsai:
Tough noogies.  He might also have discovered that Snape was, in fact,
an unrepentant Death Eater.  Harry's been right when all the adults
were wrong too many times for him to miss an opportunity like that.


Jazmyn:
>  He is a CHILD...

Amiable Dorsai:
That very notion cost Sirius Black his life.  Harry is the target of
two forces--the Ministry and Lord Voldemort--and his adult allies are
treating him like a mushroom.  If Harry takes things into his own
hands, well, what did they expect?


Jazmyn:
> Snape was in fact a lot more restrained then most people in his
> position would be.  I would likely have throttled the little git.
> How does one handle a nosey, egotistical brat who can't keep out
> of the 'Top Secret files'?? 

Amiable Dorsai:
By treating him like a human being?  


Jazmyn: 
> Harry is a loose canon who doesn't care about the consequences of
> his  actions, who leads his friends onto danger, his monstrous ego
> believing he can defeat Voldemort as nothing more then a kid.

Amiable Dorsai:
Which he has, in fact, done.  More than once. 


Jazmyn:
> Harry should be locked up before he gets anymore people killed
> or worse.  He is already responsible for leading his godfather
> to his death. 

Amiable Dorsai:
As a result of the policy of keeping him "locked up".  Why would you
wish to repeat the same mistake again?

Amiable Dorsai