[HPforGrownups] Re: Real child abuse/ Mcgonagall

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 145602

Harry is a loose canon who doesn't care about the consequences of his 
actions, who leads his friends onto danger, his monstrous ego believing 
he can defeat Voldemort as nothing more then a kid.   Harry should be 
locked up before he gets anymore people killed or worse.  He is already 
responsible for leading his godfather to his death. 

Jazmyn


Sherry now:

I think we must be reading completely different books!  the last thing I'd
accuse Harry of is being a loose cannon or having a monstrous ego.  he has
agonized over the danger his friends are in simply because of the fact that
they are his friends.  he didn't ask for the role he has been given.  He was
a baby when his parents were murdered and when the curse rebounded and he
survived.  He doesn't want this fight.

But I really cannot let the accusation about his role in the death of Sirius
pass.  It is like blaming the victim of terrorism to say that Harry is
responsible for Sirius death.  Harry reacted as anyone would react to
information that someone he loved was being held captive and tortured.  It
doesn't matter that it was a fake vision.  He had already had one real
vision, and that vision had saved Arthur's life.  he could not have acted
any other way than as he did.  The one to blame for the death of Sirius is
bella, or whoever killed her, if you buy into the idea that it could have
been someone else.  Bella and Voldemort.  Not Harry, the victim.  not Sirius
the victim either.

Sherry