Not Harry's Fault (Was Re: Real child abuse/ Mcgonagall)

[Crystal Williams]

No: HPFGUIDX 145612

Jazmyn wrote:

Harry is a loose canon who doesn't care about the consequences of his actions, who leads his friends onto danger, his monstrous ego 
believing he can defeat Voldemort as nothing more then a kid.

Sherry wrote:

<snip>
It is like blaming the victim of terrorism to say that Harry is 
responsible for Sirius death.  Harry reacted as anyone would react 
to information that someone he loved was being held captive and 
tortured.  It doesn't matter that it was a fake vision. He had 
already had one real vision, and that vision had saved Arthur's 
life.  He could not have acted any other way than as he did.  The 
one to blame for the death of Sirius is Bella, <snip>


Crystal:

I agree with Sherry! Harry even talks about how he doesn't want that 
role. He wishes he could be normal with his parents still alive. 
Harry isn't responsible for his godfather's death b/c it was Voldemort who planted the vision into his head and he acted because he thought it was real. The only people I can blame for Sirus's 
death is Voldemort and his cousin Bella. And Harry usually tries to hold his friends back but they insist on coming any ways. And he never said he definitely would be able to kill Voldemort. He isn't sure how he is going to but he's going to try.

Crystal