Portrait in GH
h2so3f
h2so3f at yahoo.com
Fri Dec 30 08:14:10 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 145613
Jen wrote:
"I've changed my mind several times but now have to go with a
portrait of Godric Gyffindor. We have yet to see any of the
Founder's portraits. That seems odd, doesn't it? Harry doesn't know
all the people in the portraits in Dumbledore's office, one could
easily be GG. Or all the Founder's pics could be on the wall of the
head's office and haven't been identified." <snip>
CH3ed:
I don't know. IMO the magic of leaving an imprint of a deceased
wizard as a portrait probably wasn't invented/discovered yet back in
the Founding Fathers' time. If there are portraits of the FF in the
Head's Office, then DD and other headmasters shouldn't have had such
a hard time finding the Chamber of Secrets... and they should have
known of certain about the existence of one (from what Binn said it
seems the CoS was considered a legend rather than factual). And the
FF portraits should have been able to tell DD what their heirlooms
are so DD and Harry wouldn't have to be guessing in HBP when they
discussed LV's possible horcruxes.
Also it seems to me if the portraits of the FF are in the office
they would be the ones the other portraits(and probably most of the
Headmasters) defer to, instead of remaining so quiet for 6 of 7
books. Also, I would think that the FF, being so revered, would be
the ones to have their portraits in MoM and other places, so DD
would have used one of two of them to go check on Arthur in OotP
rather than the 2 he used (the witch was used because her other
portrait was at St. Mungo's... but if any portrait of the FF exist
then I'd think there'd be at least one of them at St. Mungo's as
well...perhaps Ravenclaws' for inventing a cure for some bad
diseases).
Anyhow, I doubt very much that there exists a portrait of any of the
FF (or LV would be after the Slytherin one to make a horcrux out of
it, probably). But I agree with Jen that Albus and Aberforth
Dumbeldore might be Gryffindor's heirs.
CH3ed :O)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive