Taking a stab at fanfiction - some questions

M.Clifford Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Fri Feb 25 06:11:42 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125161


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Shelby Leigh 
<shelbyleigh at g...> wrote:
> 
> I have been lurking for a while, trying to get the groove of the
> group.  I have tried to keep pace with all of the posts but ... 
> well, let us say I may have missed some things.
> I am going to ask the questions.  They are research
> questions so that I can keep my characters in character and the
> storyline near canon.
>

Shelby: 
> 1. Do you think Molly and Arthur have pet names for each other? Do 
you think they married out of love?
>

Valky:
*snicker* Interesting question.
The answers IMHO are Yes (guffaw!) and Yes..

Shelby:
> 2. What about the Malfoys, did they marry out of love?  Do they 
have pet names for each other? Do they sleep in the same room? In 
the same beds?

Valky:
Hmmm this is more difficult, we know nothing about Narcissa really, 
except Sirius' somewhat one-colour opinion of all her actions. 
I would be inclined to say No Lucius probably didn't marry for love, 
I doubt he does anything "for" love or "for" anything that isn't 
himself frankly. They might *not* sleep in the same room or have any 
real relationship at all. We haven't seen it. 
 
> Shelby:
> 3. Can Crookshanks communicate with Remus when he is in his 
werewolf form? Would Crookshanks recognized Remus in his werewolf 
form?
>

Valky:
I don't think so. Canon suggest Crookshanks is an excellent 
communicator, but Werewolves as per the books are apparently 
unreachable.

Shelby: 
> 4. If Harry were unplottable would Hedwig still be able to find 
him?
>

Valky:
I would speculate yes on this one, there is definitely an emotional 
connection between them that might be more powerful than a spell.

Shelby: 
> 5. Now that Sirius is dead, would Remus kill Peter if he were to
> capture him? Would he take him back to stand trial?
> 

Valky: 
Couldn't say for sure. I think Sirius was more likely the driving 
force of the veangeful emotions so it's probably a no. Still there 
might be more to Remus than we know.

Shelby:
> Please let me know if I should not ask any other research 
question.  I apologize if this is not the correct form.
> 

Valky:
As far as I can guess they seem like valid canon topics for 
discussion, so I think all will be well with this, I think.









More information about the HPforGrownups archive