Taking a stab at fanfiction - some questions

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Fri Feb 25 21:24:13 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125191


Shelby:
 
> 1. Do you think Molly and Arthur have pet names for each other? Do 
you
> think they married out of love?

Finwitch:
Don't know about pet names, but yes, they did marry out of love. ANd 
for those two, I add a further comment: Despite of Arthur's tendency 
to smooth Molly and that 'Don't tell your Mom' - *Any* time Arthur 
Weasley expresses an opinion ('they *are* of age, Molly, dear') Molly 
stops arguing and takes his side.
 
> 2. What about the Malfoys, did they marry out of love?  Do they have
> pet names for each other? Do they sleep in the same room? In the 
same
> beds?

Finwitch:

Well, canon doesn't tell us much, but I expect their marriage was 
arranged by their families. (Black and Malfoy). We *don't* know 
anything about them, of course... about the same bed... how do you 
expect they got Draco if they never slept in the same bed?

> 3. Can Crookshanks communicate with Remus when he is in his werewolf
> form? Would Crookshanks recognized Remus in his werewolf form?

Finwitch:
Hard to say - but since a werewolf loses his mind in the 
transformation (unless being accompanied by several friendly animagi 
and/or being under the influence of Wolfsbane) that is...
 
> 4. If Harry were unplottable would Hedwig still be able to find him?

Finwitch: 

About birds finding unplottable Harry...

Hedwig -- Possibly yes, because she's Harry's Owl and there's a 
certain connection between them.

A general Owl - think not. (but we don't know how they find the 
people they're carrying letters for...)

Fawkes: YES. (hey, his tail-feather is in Harry's wand. Bet the bird 
could use that somehow...) and besides, Phoenix is powerfully magical 
and very fast...

Some other phoenix.. I think it would be possible. (hmm-- search 
entire Britain/other places of Earth?)

> 5. Now that Sirius is dead, would Remus kill Peter if he were to
> capture him? Would he take him back to stand trial?

Finwitch:

I think not. He and Sirius both agreed to let Harry decide.

Then again, since PP broke his promise and transformed (which even 
Harry seemed to agree to mean death-sentence) the answer just MIGHT 
depend on the phase of the Moon. (Nice Lupin wanting to kill? Oh, but 
it WAS full Moon - AND he just found out the rat framed Sirius... I'd 
say neither of them was very SANE that night...)

Finwitch







More information about the HPforGrownups archive