Percy Brasco?.

eggplant9998 eggplant9998 at yahoo.com
Thu Jan 6 16:41:02 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 121276


"ravenclaw001" <technomad at i...> wrote:

> Just as I am with Marietta, I am withholding
> judgement on Percy's actions until I see 
> clear proof that he wasn't acting as a long-term,
> deep-cover mole for Dumbledore at the Ministry. 

I wonder, are you withholding judgment of Umbridge's actions too? I 
doubt it, but you could make an equally strong (weak may be a better 
word) case that she was also a deep-cover mole for Dumbledore. I 
have never heard anyone actually argue this and I think I know why, 
her last name is not Weasley.

Despite what Aunt Marge says it's not true that "it's all in the 
blood", sometimes a very bad family can produce a very good person 
such as Sirius, and sometimes the opposite is true such as Percy. Is 
it possible Percy is a mole for Dumbledore? Sure. It's also possible 
pigs may fly, but some things are too unlikely to worry about. There 
will never come a time when you have ALL the information that would 
be relevant in making a decision, but there comes a time when you 
need to make a decision and make a stand.

Eggplant








More information about the HPforGrownups archive