James' Two-Way Mirror after GH & the I-Cloak

[hickengruendler]

No: HPFGUIDX 121321


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Jen Reese" <stevejjen at e...> 
wrote:
 
> 
> Jen: Well, now we know Dumbledore and the Order have more effective 
> ways to communicate since JKR wrote about that on her website. But 
> she hints the two-way mirror will have a second wind in upcoming 
> books. I guess the big question is: Who has the second mirror? 
> Surely Sirius didn't fall through the Veil with it. I doubt when he 
> heard Harry was in trouble, Sirius bothered trying to find his two-
> way mirror to take with him.
> 
> Jen, speculating Kreacher is in possession of the two-way mirror or 
> he gave it to the Malfoys.

Hickengruendler:

What I also want to know is, do only two mirrors exist? Let's say The 
Marauders invented it, like they invented the map, wouldn't it be 
logical to make a mirror for Lupin and Peter as well? Do they still 
have them? You could possibly argue that it seems unlikely that Peter 
still has the mirror, seeing that he lived as a rat for several 
years. On the other hand, James' house was destroyed and Sirius was 
in AZkaban, and still both mirrors seemed to be around during book 5.